The Collingwood watertower silhouetted against a pink Georgian Bay sunset.

Local SEO

How much do missed calls cost contractors? Count them first, then do the sum

A missed call costs a contractor the gross profit on the job it would have booked, times the odds it was a real customer, plus what you paid to make it ring.

By Lasse Pettersen ·

A missed call costs a contractor the gross profit on the job it would have booked, multiplied by the odds that the caller was a real customer. Add whatever you already paid to make the phone ring. Invoca’s 2026 home services benchmark gives the odds: 38% of answered calls are leads, and 45% of those leads book on the call. Out of 100 genuine callers, that is about 17 booked jobs, so every 100 genuine calls you miss is roughly 17 jobs that went to the next name on the list.

That is the sum. Below is where each input comes from, which of them I would not lean on, and how to replace the industry numbers with a count from your own phone.

The sum, written out

Four numbers decide what missed calls cost you in a month:

  • Missed calls that were real. Not every call that rang out, only the ones where somebody stayed on the line long enough to mean it.
  • The share of real callers who are new work. Some callers are suppliers, existing customers and price shoppers.
  • The share of new work that books. Not every lead you answer becomes an invoice either.
  • What one job leaves you. The gross profit, not the invoice total.

Add the money you spent to produce the call (an ad click, a Local Services Ads lead fee) on top, because that is gone whether or not anyone picks up.

The first number is the only one you can count exactly. The other three come from benchmarks until you have your own records, and I will say which ones are soft as we go.

How many calls are you actually missing?

Most owners believe they answer almost everything. A 2019 Service Direct call performance report, as summarised by an answering service company, found that home service professionals estimated their own answer rate at 97%, while the call data showed 66%. Those figures come from a vendor writing about a vendor’s report, and I could not find the original, so treat them as a warning about optimism rather than a measurement of you.

The newer number is lower still: Invoca’s 2026 benchmark says 52% of calls to home services businesses are answered by a person. That figure counts every call, including misdials and quick hang-ups, and Invoca gives two filtered versions for that reason:

Calls countedShare answered by a person
All inbound calls52%
Calls over 15 seconds65%
Calls over 30 seconds73%

Answer rates across the sub-industries Invoca measured ranged from 32% to 74%. A UK survey commissioned by Moneypenny, covering 300 micro businesses, found that a third of them (33%) failed to answer their incoming calls. Every one of these sources sells something to do with phone calls, which is worth knowing before you quote any of them to a partner.

Is your shop really missing a third of its calls? You do not know until you count, and the count costs nothing.

Count last month from your own phone

Open the call log on the phone that takes your business line (or the carrier’s online account, if the line forwards), and go back through all of last month. Write down every missed call, then strike out three kinds:

A checklist of seven steps for counting genuine missed calls from a phone log, from opening the log to using the remaining count in the cost sum.
The count that remains is the only one the post prices a missed call from.
  • Calls that rang for only a few seconds. Invoca’s filter at 15 seconds exists for exactly this reason: a short ring is often a misdial.
  • Repeat calls from the same number on the same day, which is one caller ringing three times rather than three customers.
  • Numbers you recognise as suppliers, telemarketers or your own family.

What is left is the first number in the sum. It will be smaller than the raw log, and it is the only count I would price a missed call from, because the raw log mixes customers with everyone else who dials a business number.

What the caller does after your voicemail picks up

The usual comfort is that a serious customer leaves a message. The data says few of them do, although the sources disagree about how few.

Invoca says its platform data shows that less than 3% of callers who get pushed to voicemail leave a message. Moneypenny’s survey put it at 69% of callers hanging up on the voicemail instead of speaking. The money page on this site quotes a third figure, and the answering service post I mentioned attributes it to Message Direct: 85% of consumers whose calls are not answered will never call back.

Three vendors, three different numbers, so which one should you believe? Where I part company with them is the precision, not the direction. None of them suggests that voicemail catches most of your missed callers, so do not count it as a backstop when you do the sum.

From missed calls to lost jobs

The middle of the sum uses Invoca’s benchmark rates, because they are the newest figures I found and they come with a sample behind them. Per 100 genuine calls:

  • 38 are leads (new work, not a supplier or a wrong number)
  • 17 of those leads book on the call (45% of 38, cut down to whole bookings)

The soft spot is an assumption I have to make out loud. Invoca measured those rates on calls that were answered, and a missed call may not behave the same way. After-hours callers may be more urgent, which would push the lead share up, and some missed callers would have been existing customers chasing an invoice, which would push it down. I have no data that settles it, so use the benchmark as a ceiling until your own records replace it.

What does that look like for a small shop? For a crew that misses about five genuine calls a week, call it 20 over a month, the sum gives roughly 8 leads and 3 booked jobs that went elsewhere. Is three jobs a month a lot? It depends entirely on what one job leaves you.

What one job leaves you, not what it invoices

Invoca’s own worked example uses a $4,500 average furnace replacement at a 20% profit margin, so about $900 a job. Why not use that margin? Because it answers a different question from the one a missed call asks of your books. Statistics Canada data published by ISED puts the average gross margin for Canadian specialty trade contractors (revenue between $30,000 and $5,000,000) at 48.4 cents on the dollar. Gross margin is the right line here because the truck, the insurance and the phone bill are paid whether the call is answered or not; a lost job loses you its materials-and-wages margin, not its net.

Take your average invoice for the kind of job that arrives by phone and multiply it by your own gross margin (your accountant has it, and it beats any average). Then multiply that by the booked-job count from your phone log. The same method sits behind the break-even sums in my local SEO ROI post, which works the other way round: how many extra jobs a monthly fee needs.

The money you spent before the phone rang

A missed call that came from an ad costs you twice. On Google Ads you pay for the click whether the call is answered or not, and the per-click prices for Collingwood trades are in the Google Ads versus SEO comparison for Collingwood trades.

Local Services Ads now charge a third time, according to Google’s advertiser email as Search Engine Roundtable quoted it. From October 1, 2026, Google bills a missed call during business hours as a valid lead once the caller has waited longer than 20 seconds, with a few exceptions. The details, including the auto-attendant exception, are in our write-up of Google’s missed-call charges. If you run LSAs and miss calls during posted hours, a missed call is no longer free to the ad account even before you count the lost job.

What I would do with the number

Can you fix this without buying anything? Often, yes, and you should try first.

  • Count last month, as above, and work out the booked jobs it implies at your own margin.
  • Look at when the misses happen. If they bunch at the same time of day (the morning dispatch, the lunch run), moving who carries the phone at that hour is free.
  • Check what a caller hears. A voicemail greeting that names the business and says texting works is a short job.
  • Check where a text goes. Google Maps now puts a Message button beside Call on your Business Profile, and it sends the customer to the number in your profile’s Chat field. Text that number yourself and make sure it reaches a phone someone carries.
  • Do the sum again next month and see whether the count moved.

If a person can answer your phone all day, you do not need a text-back at all, and I would rather you kept the money. The case for one is narrower: the count says you miss genuine callers every week, and the reason is that your hands are on a job, not that nobody is assigned to the phone. Then a missed call text back service sends the caller a text from your business within seconds and tells you who called. If you would like someone to look at the whole path first, from the search to the ring, a free local SEO audit is where I would start, and the answer it gives may be that the phone is not the problem.

Frequently asked questions

How do I calculate how much a missed call costs my business?

Count the genuine missed calls from last month in your phone log, leaving out short rings and repeat calls. Multiply by the share that are new work and the share of those that book (Invoca’s 2026 benchmark gives 38% and 45%). Multiply the result by the gross profit on a typical job, then add any ad spend that produced those calls.

Do customers leave a voicemail when a contractor misses the call?

Mostly not: Invoca reports that less than 3% of callers pushed to voicemail leave a message, and Moneypenny found 69% hang up instead. The sources disagree on the exact figure, but none of them treats voicemail as a reliable way to keep the caller.

Does Google charge for missed Local Services Ads calls?

Yes: since October 1, 2026, Google bills a missed call during business hours as a lead once the caller has waited longer than 20 seconds. That rule, with some exceptions, comes from Google’s advertiser email as quoted by Search Engine Roundtable.

What is a normal call answer rate for a trade business?

Invoca’s 2026 benchmark puts it at 52% of all calls answered by a person, and 73% for calls longer than 30 seconds, with sub-industries ranging from 32% to 74%. Your own phone log is a better number than any of these, and it takes an evening to read.

Want this run against your own business?

Free 15-minute audit. We pull up Google together and show you exactly where you rank, where you could be in 60 to 90 days, and the cheapest moves to get there.

Free Growth Roadmap More Google Reviews