Ask customers for reviews on the day the work is finished and working, by text with your Google review link, sent around noon or in the early evening. If the customer has to live with the work before they can judge it (a new roof, a renovation, fresh sod), wait until they have. Send one reminder at most (only if no review came), and never inside the first week. In a seasonal Georgian Bay trade, ask hardest in the last weeks of the season. Each interval has a reason, and the evidence under some of them is thinner than I would like.
Asking at all matters more than any interval on this page. BrightLocal’s 2026 consumer survey found that 78% of consumers were asked to write a review in the last 12 months, with 65% writing one after being asked. My own judgment is that most trades along the Georgian Bay shoreline have an asking problem rather than a timing problem. Timing only starts to matter once the ask goes out after every job.
The first ask goes out on the day the job is done
A 2024 working paper from Paderborn University read 22.3 million review requests and 2.3 million reviews from Trusted Shops, which it describes as one of Europe’s largest online shop certifiers and review platforms. Its finding is plain: “the probability of receiving a review decreases as the time between the purchase and the request increases.” The same paper found two peaks in the day, “around noon and early evening”, when requests drew a substantially higher response rate.
I want to be honest about what that evidence is. It is online shops in Europe, not plumbers in Collingwood or electricians in Barrie, and I have no trade data of that size to set beside it. I still lean on it (with that caveat attached), because the mechanism carries over. A customer whose basement drain runs again tonight remembers your name tonight, and by next Thursday you are one of six tradespeople they dealt with this year.
What does “the day the job is done” look like on a real account? For one account, another Guelph business where the ask goes out by text on the day the customer collects an order, the laundromat case study lays out the review counts before and after, along with the other work that landed in the same weeks. Treat one account as one account.
Asking in person, and asking for the review on the spot
Can you not just ask while you are standing in the kitchen? Yes, and you should say it out loud as well as send the link. The line to stay behind is Google’s: its policy bars merchants from pressuring a customer into a rating or a written review while that customer is still on the premises. Saying “you will get a text from us with a link” is an ask. Standing over the customer until they post is where I would stop.
When finished is not the same as judged
The Paderborn paper also found that shops selling high-involvement and experience goods “should wait longer before sending out review requests to customers, post-purchase.” A second study, published in the Journal of Marketing in 2023, makes the same point for experience goods such as restaurants and travel: “it may be prudent to provide consumers enough time to evaluate the product before sending a review reminder.”
A service call is judged the moment it ends. A roof is judged in the first heavy rain, and a basement renovation is judged after the family has lived in it. The table below is how I sort trades on that question, and it is my judgment applied to the research, not a measured result for each row.
| The job | When the first ask goes out | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Drain clearing, a faucet swap, an electrical repair | The same day | The problem is gone when you leave, so the customer can already judge it |
| Furnace or air conditioner replacement | The same day | The house is warm or cool before you drive away |
| Roof, siding, windows | After the customer has seen it through weather | The work is not judged until it has had to perform |
| Renovation, landscaping, new sod | After the customer has lived with it | Small faults show up in the first weeks of use |
If you want a fixed number of days for the slow rows, my Collingwood SEO page for trades sets one for high-ticket work. The principle matters more than the count: ask at the point the customer can honestly say the job worked.
One reminder, and why sooner is worse
The second study is the one that surprised me. In its first experiment, researchers randomly assigned customers of a South Korean travel site to a review reminder at one of several intervals, from the day after the event to 13 days later, and compared each group with a control group that got no reminder. Of those reminded the day after, 6.32% posted a review within a week, while 12% of the control group did. That is roughly half the rate of the people nobody reminded.
Why would a polite nudge make people less likely to write? The researchers put it down to psychological reactance, and one of them described the request as driving away the customer’s own motivation to write. Reminders sent at 13 days, by contrast, drew significantly more reviews than no reminder at all. The authors put the rule in one sentence: “reminders cause problems when they are sent faster than the number of days it takes, on average, for customers to write a review.”
The same research leans on an industry survey that found most people took at least two days to post a review, and more than half took more than five. For a trade, that gives a simple rule:
- Send the first ask on the day the job can be judged.
- If no review arrives, send one reminder after the first week, and later still if you can wait.
- Then stop, and never ask the same customer again for the same job.
Will a later reminder bring in angrier reviews? The study found that, except for how specific a review was, “the timing of review reminders has a negligible effect on review content such as ratings, sentiment, or length.” I would still label this evidence carefully: it comes from South Korean travel and apparel marketplaces, and it tested review reminders, not the first ask.
The season, on the Georgian Bay shoreline
Timing has a calendar side as well as a clock side, and it hits seasonal trades hardest. BrightLocal’s 2026 survey put the share of consumers who only care about reviews from the past three months at 74%. That number matters most to a business that stops working for part of the year.
Take a landscaper or a dock installer (anyone whose work stops with the frost) whose last job of the year is in early November. By the time the phone starts ringing again in spring, the newest review on the profile is older than three months, and the competitor who kept working through the winter looks more alive. The same arithmetic runs in reverse for a ski tuning shop near Blue Mountain whose busy season ends in April.
Two habits follow from that. Ask every customer in the closing weeks of your season, including the small jobs you would normally skip, because those reviews are the ones a spring customer reads first. Then ask any off-season customer too (the snow removal contract, the winter emergency call), because one recent review in February beats none.
Is that a real problem in this market, or a theoretical one? My Review Engine page reports the town-wide reading for Collingwood: two thirds of the town gained no reviews at all over the 26 days to 17 September. For a seasonal trade, how many Google reviews it takes to rank in Collingwood matters less than whether the newest one is recent.
Every customer, on the same clock
A timing rule has to apply to every customer in the same job type, whatever kind of day they seemed to have. Google’s policy forbids merchants from discouraging negative reviews or from soliciting only the positive ones. In my reading, asking only after the jobs that went well comes too close to that selective soliciting. Local SEO Answers, the question site Georgian Bay SEO runs, covers the wording side of this in how to ask customers for Google reviews without breaking Google’s rules.
That is also why I prefer a timing rule written down by job type. “Drain calls get the text the same day” is a rule anyone in the office can follow, and it does not depend on the technician’s mood at the end of a long shift.
Doing it yourself, and when to pay for it
Can you run this schedule yourself? Yes, and many owners should keep their money. Google’s help page names two ways to send a customer to your review form, a Google link or a QR code, and explains how to create both. A saved text message, a note on the job sheet and a reminder in your calendar (set for the day the reminder is due) cover the whole schedule above. The free Review Harvest Kit has 24 copy-paste templates for that message.
What runs out is not knowledge but the habit. The ask slips in the busiest weeks, which are exactly the weeks with the most customers to ask. That gap is what my Google review management service for busy trades, the Review Engine, covers at $149 a month, no contract. The page sets a 30-day minimum between texts to any one customer and honours every opt-out, which is stricter than the one-reminder rule above.
If reviews are only one part of a quieter profile, start with the free local SEO audit, which will also tell you when a saved text message is all you need.
Frequently asked questions
How soon after a job should I ask for a review?
On the day the customer can judge the work, which for most service calls is the same day. A large study of online shops found that the chance of a review falls as the gap between purchase and request grows. For a roof or a renovation, wait until the customer has lived with the work.
What time of day should I send a review request?
The Paderborn study of 22.3 million requests found peaks “around noon and early evening”. For a trade, that means the text goes out at lunch or after dinner, not first thing in the morning while the customer is getting the kids to school.
How many times can I ask the same customer for a review?
Once, plus one reminder at most. In one field study, 6.32% of customers reminded the day after posted a review within a week, against 12% of customers who got no reminder. Reminders sent 13 days after the event drew significantly more reviews than no reminder at all. Send the reminder after the first week, then stop.
Should I only ask customers who were happy?
No. Google’s policy forbids soliciting only the positive reviews, and asking only the happy customers does exactly that. Ask every customer at the same point in the job, and answer the unhappy reviews well when they come.
Want this run against your own business?
Free 15-minute audit. We pull up Google together and show you exactly where you rank, where you could be in 60 to 90 days, and the cheapest moves to get there.
Prefer to talk? (705) 539-0398