The downtown Collingwood welcome sign on a clear day.

Reviews

Collingwood review growth through October 2026: 554 new reviews in 46 days

We re-read 22 Collingwood service categories on 2 November. The panel added 554 Google reviews in 46 days, more than twice September's pace. Auto shops led.

By Lasse Pettersen ·

We re-read the same 22 Collingwood service categories on 2 November, 46 days after the September update. Across the 338 established businesses we could read in both pulls, the town added 554 Google reviews, a rise of 2.9%. That is more than twice the pace we measured in September. The growth also spread out: the ten fastest businesses took 46% of it, down from 89%. What did not change is the size of the group doing nothing. 197 of the 338 added no reviews at all.

What changed between 17 September and 2 November

17 September2 NovemberChange
Businesses tracked in both pulls338338fixed panel
Google reviews held by the panel18,86619,420+554 (+2.9%)
Businesses that added at least one12236% of the panel
Businesses that added nothing19758%
Businesses whose count fell196%
Typical gain among those that moved+2median

There was no October entry, so this window runs 46 days instead of a month. To compare the two windows fairly, we took the 268 businesses with at least one review in August that we could read in all three pulls (August, September and November). They added 139 reviews in the 26 days to 17 September, about 160 per 30 days. They added 586 in the 46 days to 2 November, about 382 per 30 days. The town is collecting reviews more than twice as fast this autumn as it was at the end of summer.

The panel is fixed on purpose. It holds only businesses we could read in both sweeps, matched on their Google place ID, with the same locality and category rules applied to each pull. A listing that moves in or out of the results is a change in what Google returned, not a change in the business, so it counts as neither growth nor loss.

Auto and home systems took 60% of the growth

GroupBusinesses in the panelReviews addedShare of the growth
Auto repair, oil change, detailing46+17431%
HVAC, plumbing, electrical, appliance repair72+16229%
Landscaping, tree, roofing, window cleaning, painting133+11220%

Inside each group a business counts once, even when it ranks in more than one category. Eleven businesses sit in two groups, so the rows do not add to a single total.

The pattern follows the calendar. October and early November are tire changeover and furnace season in this town. We did not measure job volume, but the categories that collected the most reviews are the ones that are busiest in those weeks. Forty-six auto businesses added more reviews than 133 outdoor and exterior businesses combined. The outdoor trades are finishing their season, and most of them added nothing in these 46 days.

If you run a seasonal business, your busiest weeks are your review weeks. A review left in October works for you all winter, while you are not on the tools.

The ten fastest movers

BusinessRating17 Sep2 NovGain
Mr. Lube + Tires4.8641709+68
Affordable Comfort5.01,1021,142+40
Air Source Home Comfort5.0289319+30
Lyfted Home Services5.02654+28
Current Plumbing - Heating & Cooling5.0382402+20
Speedy Glass Collingwood4.9183200+17
Master Mechanic Collingwood4.7331347+16
JS Repair Inc. of Collingwood5.0136149+13
Modern PURAIR Collingwood5.03244+12
Horizon Property Management5.0137149+12

Five of these ten were on the September list too. Affordable Comfort, Current Plumbing, Mr. Lube, Modern PURAIR and Horizon Property Management are all adding at a steady rate, month after month. That is what a working review habit looks like from the outside: not a spike, a line.

The entry to copy this time is Lyfted Home Services. It went from 26 reviews to 54 in 46 days, more than doubling its count. A handyman business at 54 reviews now sits well above the Collingwood median of 16. Modern PURAIR did the same thing on a smaller scale, from 32 to 44, after adding ten in the September window.

The plumbing listing that jumped to 65 has stopped

In September we reported a plumbing listing that went from zero reviews to 65 in 26 days and took first place in the plumber results. On 2 November it still shows 65 reviews. It has not added a single one in 46 days, while the established plumbers around it kept adding at their normal rate.

We are not going to guess what happened. The data shows one listing that collected 65 reviews in under a month, and then none in the next six weeks. A business that earns reviews from real jobs does not usually stop at once.

One count fell by a fifth

Nineteen businesses show a lower count in November than in September. Most lost one or two reviews. Google removes reviews it judges to breach its policies, reviewers delete their own, and profiles sometimes get merged. A loss of one or two is normal.

One moving company is different. It held 87 reviews in August, 84 in September and 66 in November, a loss of 18 in 46 days and a fifth of its count. We do not name businesses for bad results. If your own count drops by more than a few, read your recent reviews and check where they came from before you assume Google made a mistake.

What Collingwood business owners should do now

Ask after every finished job, in the same sentence you use to confirm the work is done. In this window, 58% of the town added nothing in 46 days. Two reviews a month puts you ahead of most of your competitors.

Ask hardest in your busy season. Several of the auto shops and furnace companies above are franchise locations with a built-in review ask. The rest had a busy month and asked.

Check your own count against your category median before you spend money on visibility. If you have fewer than 16 reviews in Collingwood, reviews are the cheapest ranking work available to you. Our free reputation scan puts your number against your category median and the leader in about a minute.

For the full picture behind these numbers, the Collingwood Review Index 2026 covers the concentration, the category leaders and the wide open trades, and how many Google reviews it takes to rank in Collingwood covers the thresholds by trade. For the local search picture around the reviews, start with the Collingwood local SEO playbook or the Collingwood area page.

How this is measured, and what it is not

The November pull ran the same 22 categories from the same map centre as the August and September collections, three pages deep per category, through the same search API we use for client work. Every listing goes through the locality rules published with the annual index: an addressed listing must carry a Collingwood address, an addressless listing must answer on an Ontario or toll free number, and retail counters, dealership service desks and listings that are not providers in their category are dropped.

The November pull found 385 Collingwood businesses holding 23,703 reviews, against 398 and 22,450 in September. Those two totals are not a measure of change. Google Maps returns a different depth of results for the same query from one pull to the next, so the businesses found change even when no review is written. That is why the panel exists, and why the headline on this page is +554.

Listings that held zero reviews in September are out of the panel, so a standing start never counts as growth. Named businesses are limited to a rating of 4.4 or higher.

Frequently asked questions

Why is this window 46 days and not a month? We skipped the mid-October reading, so this entry covers 17 September to 2 November. To compare it with September we converted both windows to a 30-day rate, using only the 268 businesses we could read in all three pulls.

Why did review growth speed up? The groups that grew fastest, auto service and home heating, are the ones whose busy season falls in October. More jobs means more chances to ask. The data cannot prove the cause, but the timing and the categories point the same way.

How many reviews a month should I be getting? Four is the number we give clients. The median business that moved at all added two in 46 days, and more than half the town added none. Four a month reaches the town median of 16 in four months from a standing start, and passes it in the fifth.

Will you publish this every month? That is the plan. Same categories, same centre, same depth, same rules, with the annual edition continuing to carry the deep analysis each July. The next reading is due in mid-December.

Want this run against your own business?

Free 15-minute audit. We pull up Google together and show you exactly where you rank, where you could be in 60 to 90 days, and the cheapest moves to get there.

Free Growth Roadmap More Google Reviews