An unfollowed estimate costs you the margin on a job you could have won, multiplied by the chance that one more message would have turned silence into an answer. One software vendor’s quote data puts the silent share at about 33% of quotes sent. For a deck builder sending 20 quotes a month, that is roughly 7 quotes with no reply, and at most 3 decks’ worth of margin if a follow-up wins half of them. That is a ceiling, not a forecast.
The vendor figure is usable with care, and there are two places where it bends; both are covered below. The inputs you can replace with your own records come first, because your records beat anybody’s benchmark.
Silent is not the same as lost
A lost quote has an answer attached to it. The customer said no, picked somebody cheaper, or put the job off until next year, and you know where you stand. A silent quote has nothing attached, and most owners file it with the losses because that is the tidy place to put a job you never heard about again.
Why does the difference matter? Because the two need different fixes, and only one of them is a follow-up problem. A lost quote is a question about price or scope, and a polite text changes neither. A silent quote is a question nobody asked, and it is the only pile that a follow-up can do anything about.
BuildOps, whose quote data I use below, says its analysis of thousands of quotes sent since January 2024 found that about 33% of quotes go unanswered. It also says that once a quote gets answered, 92% of the time it turns into a job. Its headline puts it plainly: the real roadblock is silence rather than rejection.
Where the one-in-three figure comes from, and how far I trust it
I would use the 33% and discount the 92%, and the reason is who sent the quotes.
The 33% counts quotes that went unanswered. Nothing about it should depend much on what the customer is buying: people get busy, a quote slides down an inbox, and on the contractor’s side nobody owns the job of asking again. I would expect a homeowner in Wasaga Beach to go quiet about as easily as a property manager in Barrie (that is my read, not a measurement, and I would be glad to see a residential count that proves me wrong).
The 92% needs more care. BuildOps calls its product the platform built for commercial contractors, and I expect commercial service quotes behave differently from residential bids. A homeowner collecting several bids for a fence is not in the position of a building manager approving a repair from the shop that already services the building. I would not carry 92% over to residential work. Use your own close rate on answered quotes instead; it is in your books.
The report also compares shops. Its best contractors (“Top Shops”) get 19% more responses, and its example sets Top Shops closer to 85% response rates against a shop with responses on 66% of its quotes. The same page asks you to book a demo of the BuildOps platform, so I read the comparison as a sales argument with some data in it.
The sum, for a deck builder in Collingwood
How big is the silent pile for one ordinary shop? Take a made-up deck and fence builder working Collingwood, Thornbury and Blue Mountain, and change every input to your own.
| Input | Value in the example | Where it comes from |
|---|---|---|
| Quotes sent last month | 20 | Your sent folder or quoting software |
| Share that got no reply at all | 33%, so about 7 quotes | BuildOps quote data, until you count your own |
| A typical quote | $5,500, a 12 by 12 pressure-treated deck | RenoQuotes 2026: a budget starting at around $5,500 for that deck |
| Gross margin | 48.4 cents of each dollar | Statistics Canada figures for specialty trades, published by ISED |
| Your close rate on quotes that do reply | Half | An assumption; use your own |
The ceiling is the case where a follow-up gets all 7 silent customers to reply and you win half of them, which is 3 decks (rounded down to whole decks). The arithmetic floor is zero, because if nobody replies the sum is zero. The smallest result worth paying for is one revived deck. At 48.4 cents of each dollar, each of those decks leaves you a little under half of the $5,500 invoice, so even one is a real number in a month when the crew has open days.
Why margin and not the invoice total? Because the overheads on the shop (insurance, vehicles, the office) are paid whether a quote is answered or not, so the money a silent quote takes away is the materials-and-wages margin on the job. The 48.4 cents is the ISED average for Canadian specialty trade contractors in the $30,000 to $5,000,000 revenue band. The figure your bookkeeper gives you for your own shop is better than any average.
Where does the real figure land? Somewhere between the floor and the ceiling. Some silent customers already hired another builder. Some were never going to build this year, and a follow-up only reaches the ones still deciding. I have not counted this for any shop, and nobody can give you that share in advance, so the table stops at the range.
Count your own silent quotes
Open your sent folder, sort last month’s quotes by date, and put each one into one of three piles:
- Won. The customer approved, paid a deposit or booked a date.
- Lost, with an answer. A no, a price objection, a “maybe next year”. These are not part of this sum.
- Silent. No reply of any kind since the day you sent it.
The third pile is the one this post is about. Multiply it by your close rate on the first two piles together (won, divided by won plus lost), then by the margin on a typical job, and you have your own ceiling. It is the table above with your numbers in place of the vendor’s, and it usually takes less time than pricing one deck.
Can you not just text them yourself?
Yes. Most owners with fewer than ten quotes a month should, and here is the size of the job. For the 7 silent quotes in the example, three short texts each comes to 21 messages a month, which is one sitting if you keep a list and a much bigger job if you rely on memory between site visits.
The real cost is not the typing. Following up feels awkward and has no fixed slot in the week, so it slips behind the work that pays today. If you already run a Friday list of open quotes and work through it, you do not need to pay anybody for this, and the sum above is mostly a reason to keep doing what you do.
What should the messages say? Short, in your business’s name, about the quote they asked for, and easy to answer either way: a yes, a no or a question all close the loop. A “no” is worth having, because it moves a quote from the silent pile to the lost pile and tells you something about your price.
Quotes that go quiet for the winter
One local wrinkle changes the schedule. Along the Georgian Bay shoreline a lot of outdoor work (decks, docks, fences, landscaping) is quoted in the fall for a start once the ground allows it. I have not counted this locally, but a quote sent in late October for a spring deck is not silent in the usual sense; the customer may simply have nothing to decide until March, and pressing them in November does not help.
For those, follow up once to confirm the quote arrived and that the customer has what they need, then put a reminder in your calendar for early spring and ask again then. A short sequence that runs its course in a week cannot cover a gap that lasts the whole winter.
When paying for follow-up is the better buy
Turn the same sum around and it prices any service that does this for you. If one revived job a month leaves more margin than the monthly fee, the fee pays for itself; if your count says nothing goes silent, no fee is cheap. Estimate Engine, our estimate follow up service for trades, chases every quote until it is answered, and for an owner already on the Review Engine it is $99 a month as an add-on.
It is the better buy under one condition. Your count says you send quotes every week, a real share of them go silent, and the reason is that you are on the tools when the follow-up should happen rather than that nobody decided to do it. That is my read, not a measurement: if you send two quotes a year, it is the wrong purchase.
A quote is the middle of a longer path. The step before it is the phone, and how much missed calls cost contractors runs the same kind of count on calls that never reach you. The local SEO ROI for contractors post does the break-even sum for a monthly retainer instead, and our local SEO pricing in Ontario page lists what each plan costs. If you would like a second pair of eyes on the whole path first, a free local SEO audit looks at it end to end, and it may say the quote is not where your money leaks.
Frequently asked questions
What are my unanswered quotes costing me?
Count last month’s quotes that got no reply at all, leaving out every one with a yes or a no. Multiply that count by your close rate on the quotes that did answer, then by the margin on a typical job. The result is a ceiling, because not every silent customer was still in the market.
How many quotes go unanswered for a typical contractor?
The best figure I found is BuildOps’ analysis of thousands of quotes sent since January 2024: about 33% go unanswered. BuildOps describes its platform as built for commercial contractors, so treat the figure as a starting point until your own count replaces it.
Should I charge for an estimate?
That depends on how much work the estimate takes and how many of them you win. A fair condition is to charge when a site visit and a drawing take a big part of your day and you win fewer than one quote in three. Whichever way you go, the follow-up question stays the same: a quote that nobody asks about again is the one you cannot win.
How many quotes do homeowners get before hiring a contractor?
I have no sourced count of how many bids a homeowner collects, so I assume three as a working guess. The point holds either way: assume you are not the only quote on the table, and that is the strongest reason to send the first polite follow-up within a day or two, while your quote is still near the top of the pile.
Want this run against your own business?
Free 15-minute audit. We pull up Google together and show you exactly where you rank, where you could be in 60 to 90 days, and the cheapest moves to get there.
Prefer to talk? (705) 539-0398